| 2003 | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008 |
2009 | |
| Supporting Actor | John McEnroe “Mr. Deeds | Bob Newhart “Elf.” | Steve Carrell “Anchorman.” | Paul Rudd “The 40-Year-Old Virgin” | Dustin Hoffman “Stranger Than Fiction” | Paul Rudd, “Knocked Up” |
Russell Brand, "Forgetting Sarah Marshall" |
| Supporting Actress | Rosamund Pike “Die Another Day.” | Queen Latifah “Chicago.” | Cathere Zeta-Jones, “Ocean’s Twelve.” | None | Queen Latifah, “Stranger Than Fiction.” | Jennifer Hudson, “Dreamgirls” |
Allison Janney, "Juno" |
| Actor | Adam Sandler “Mr. Deeds” | Will Ferrell “Old School.” | Will Farrell “Anchorman.” | Vince Vaughn, “Wedding Crashers.” | Will Ferrell, “Talladega Nights.” | Matt Damon, “The Bourne Ultimatum” |
Jason Segal, "Forgetting Sarah Marshall" |
| Actress | Nia Vardalos “My Big, Fat Greek Wedding.” | Kiera Knightly “Love Actually.” | Christe Taylor, “Dodgeball.” | Isla Fisher, “Wedding Crashers.” | Kate Becksale, “Click.” | Amy Adams, “Enchanted” |
"Ellen Page, "Juno" |
| Bridget | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A | “Ice Age: The Meltdown.” | “Enchanted” |
"Kung Fu Panda" |
| Movie | “Big Trouble.” | “Old School.” | “Dodgeball.” | “Wedding Crashers.” | “Talladega Nights.” | “Knocked Up” |
"High School Musical 3" |